We found the Anthropologie Everlee Bath Caddy to be more stylish than functional. Its narrow frame didn’t hold much aside from a drinking glass and candle; adding a book or electronic device felt too precarious. Despite the sealant over the teak wood, noticeable fading and inconsistencies appeared in the wood’s coloring after just a few uses, and the decorative brass handles were too large to fit comfortably across the tub.The Anthropologie Maison Storage Bath Caddy is difficult to adjust—it comes with a tiny, thin Allen wrench that feels breakable as you use it—and due to the deep angle of its arms, it can’t balance in baths with smaller basins (the basin we tested in was 22 inches wide). This tray also sits very deep, and in our tests we found that it would press into the legs of bathers, becoming uncomfortable to use.The Bambüsi Bamboo Bathtub Caddy Tray is a sturdy tray with a book/tablet holder and a secure wine-glass slot, but the finish on the wood has a chintzy and cheap feel. And the tray’s massive length—starting at 27½ inches and expanding all the way to 41½ inches—made it difficult to adjust inside our bath. If you like this kind of larger, wooden bath tray, we’d recommend the Royal Craft Wood tray over the Bambüsi.Bed Bath & Beyond’s Haven Teakwood Bathtub Caddy had rough, unfinished wood that felt thin and poor-quality—our test unit had large cracks. The caddy has a book holder, but it’s only an outline of wood with a large, empty center that smaller books could easily fall through.Similar to our Monsuri pick, the Belmint Expandable Bamboo Bathtub Tray had plenty of useful compartments and was easy to store, but we found that the lack of rubber grips made the tray unstable, and the lacquered finish was prone to scratches and dents.The Madesmart Expandable Bath Shelf is one of the cheapest models we tested (second only to the Mind Reader), and although it’s lightweight and very sturdy in a bath, we thought the plastic material felt and looked cheap in comparison with other models. In addition, the larger side handles easily gather dust and grime, which the white plastic readily shows.Royal Craft Wood’s Bamboo Bathtub Caddy Tray is one of the larger trays we tested. Although we concluded that it was unwieldy and too big for small to standard-size tubs, we think it’s a good choice for tubs that are 32 inches wide or more. It’s a well-crafted tray with removable compartments, a separate soap dish, a book/tablet stand, a wine-glass holder, and a phone slot.The suction attachment of the Uncommon Goods Swivel Bath Tray caught our eye as an interesting solution for alcove baths that don’t have an inner ledge for a tray to sit on. But it wobbled in our testing, and it did not sit level after we placed it on the side of the tub. Plus, although it’s an oval tray, the corners of each wooden slat are sharp, making it a minor hazard to brush up against.
Source link